Rate Brief ENDE

BoJ October opinions: one member puts neutral well above 1%, others urge caution

The Bank of Japan published the Summary of Opinions from its 29-30 October Monetary Policy Meeting on 10 November. The board kept the policy rate unchanged at that meeting; the summary shows members agreeing on the direction of policy but not on its speed.

On the economy, members described a moderate recovery with some weakness linked to the situation in the Middle East, private consumption without momentum, and AI-related demand that has supported activity mainly through semiconductor materials, equipment and data centres, which one member said made its durability worth watching. Another argued that the deflationary norm has been dispelled and that Japan's economy has returned to normal business cycles linked with developments abroad. On prices, members judged underlying CPI inflation broadly consistent with the 2 percent target, with next year's spring wage talks a key test; one opinion projected CPI excluding fresh food rising above 3 percent toward the end of the fiscal year, and another warned that inflation in Japan is less firmly anchored at 2 percent than in Europe and the United States.

The monetary policy section shows the range. Some members said a little more examination of risks and of the cumulative effects of past hikes justified holding. Others argued the Bank should keep raising rates and decide the next hike when it can without being overly cautious. One opinion called the present a new phase in which the Bank needs to step up the pace towards the neutral rate; another said the Bank should reach neutral soon but make haste slowly, watching financial conditions for a few months after each move. One member said the neutral rate is likely considerably above 1 percent, while another noted the policy rate has already entered the estimated range of the neutral rate and warned that a further hike could weigh on underlying inflation.

Two opinions supported changing the pace of the Bank's sales of exchange-traded funds, which began in January, citing smooth execution and higher stock market trading, while paying attention to effects on corporate governance. Government representatives from the Ministry of Finance and the Cabinet Office said they expect the Bank to decide as appropriate.

BoJ October opinions: one member puts neutral well above 1%, others urge caution
BoJ October opinions: one member puts neutral well above 1%, others urge caution — Rate Brief

What it means

The summary shows a board that has moved past whether to keep raising rates. The open question is how far away neutral is, and members disagree on that by a wide margin.

Written by Victoria Shinder.