BoJ's Asada explains his votes against the June and September hikes and urges care on pace
Bank of Japan Policy Board member Toichiro Asada set out on 12 November why he voted against both rate increases this year, in a speech to local leaders in Nagasaki. The Bank raised its policy rate in June and September, taking it to 1.25%, the highest in around three decades. Asada dissented both times and voted to hold at the July and October meetings.
His reasoning turns on how restrictive policy has already become. The Bank estimates the natural rate of interest at slightly above minus 1% to plus 0.5%, which puts the neutral rate, after adding expected inflation, at slightly above 1% to 2.5%. The range is wide, Asada acknowledged, but the policy rate is already inside it. When the Bank began raising rates from well below neutral, the downside risk of each hike was small because conditions stayed loose. Now, he argued, further hikes are more likely to slow real activity and, through that, push underlying inflation down.
He sees signs of that risk in consumption. The Bank officially describes private spending as resilient, and Asada said he would not call it weak, but he believes it is not strong enough to drive growth. Real private consumption was almost flat in the April to June quarter, though he attributed part of that to institutional factors, and the Bank's Consumption Activity Index points the same way.
On prices, he described a strong push from upstream. Import prices in yen terms have risen sharply because of the situation in the Middle East, AI-related demand and the weaker yen, and producer price inflation is around 7%. Consumer inflation excluding fresh food is around 2%, held down by government energy subsidies, and excluding fresh food and energy around 2.5%. Medium to long-term inflation expectations are about 2%.
Asada accepted the Bank's October Outlook Report view that the risk of underlying inflation overshooting 2% needs attention. But he argued that recent price increases are not necessarily demand-driven, and that further hikes should come when higher wages are feeding demand-led inflation. He welcomed real wages being positive since the start of 2026, after three years of substantial base pay increases, and said the Bank should give due consideration to the pace of any further moves. He closed with remarks on the Bank's sales of exchange-traded funds.

Why it matters
Dissents tell markets where the debate on the board sits. Asada is not arguing that inflation is under control; he is arguing that with the policy rate inside the neutral range, the cost of each additional hike has risen. That framing gives the hawks a clear test: evidence that demand, not import costs, is now driving prices.