Rate Brief ENDE

Makhlouf on industrial policy: be open-minded, but keep Europe open

Gabriel Makhlouf, Governor of the Central Bank of Ireland, opened a CEPR, University College Dublin and Central Bank of Ireland workshop on industrial policy in Dublin on 13 November; the BIS published his remarks on 19 November. He defined industrial policy as targeting specific firms or sectors to change the composition of economic activity through government action rather than leaving it to the market, and said the long taboo on it is gone, citing Paul Krugman's shift from sceptic to cautious supporter and a World Bank policy report reversing its own stance of 30 years ago.

Makhlouf placed the renewed interest in Europe's productivity problem. US labour productivity growth fell from 2.7% a year in 1995-2007 to 1.3% in 2007-2019, he said, while in the larger European economies it fell from 1.3% to 0.5%. The US spends around 3.5% of GDP on research and development against around 2.2% in Europe, high-productivity European firms find it harder to scale up, and capital markets remain fragmented and reliant on bank debt.

He urged caution. Industrial policy can quickly become a large expense for the state, and he worried that Europe might turn "open strategic autonomy" into a pursuit of resilience but forget the word "open", cutting itself off from flows of ideas, capital and people. Citing Ireland's own history - an inward-looking, high-tariff strategy from the 1930s to the 1950s with disappointing results, then openness to trade and investment and EEC membership in 1973 - he said Irish policies worked best when combined with openness and investment in education.

Makhlouf on industrial policy: be open-minded, but keep Europe open
Makhlouf on industrial policy: be open-minded, but keep Europe open — Rate Brief

Why it matters

A central banker is not the one who designs industrial policy, but he pays for its fiscal and inflation consequences. Makhlouf's caution is aimed at the cost and at the risk that protection outlives its reason.

Written by Victoria Shinder.