Rate Brief ENDE

ECB's Elderson proposes a €10 billion small-bank threshold that would add about 150 banks

Frank Elderson, member of the ECB's Executive Board and Vice-Chair of its Supervisory Board, set out proposals for lighter oversight of smaller banks in a contribution for Börsen-Zeitung published on 16 November. Around 75% of the banks supervised by national authorities in the euro area - more than 1,400 institutions - already qualify as small and non-complex, he wrote; in Germany the share is 81%. They report up to 30% of the data their larger counterparts report.

The proposals, worked out by the ECB and national supervisors, build on that framework rather than creating a new one. To qualify today, a bank must have a balance sheet below €5 billion. Elderson wrote that consolidation among German regional banks has created larger institutions without making them riskier, so the regulation should allow national authorities to raise the threshold to €10 billion where a bank's risk profile and the domestic sector justify it. "Non-complex" should also be redefined, since some banks are excluded for technical reasons related to resolution planning. Together, these changes would bring about 150 more banks under the framework.

In supervisory practice, he wrote, some exercises could be run less often or more efficiently for banks with stable, well-understood risk profiles; supervisors could run stress test projections centrally rather than have banks do them, lightening the load for almost 1,000 institutions. With the European Banking Authority, the ECB is pursuing reforms that should cut reporting by small and non-complex banks to around 5% of the data points large banks report.

"Greater proportionality cannot mean lower standards," Elderson wrote, adding that depositors in a small regional bank should have the same confidence as customers of a large international one.

ECB's Elderson proposes a €10 billion small-bank threshold that would add about 150 banks
ECB's Elderson proposes a €10 billion small-bank threshold that would add about 150 banks — Rate Brief

Why it matters

The threshold change needs an amendment to the regulation; the supervisory changes - central stress test projections and less reporting - are things the supervisors say they are already working on. The difference matters for how soon banks would see the effect.

Written by Victoria Shinder.