Schnabel says Europe lacks scale, not ideas, and calls a 28th company-law regime a game changer
Isabel Schnabel, a member of the ECB's Executive Board, argued in a speech at the Bank of Lithuania on 13 November that the story of a declining Europe is appealing but misleading, and that what Europe lacks is not talent, ideas or research but scale. Her proposed remedy is a 28th regime, a single European corporate framework that firms could choose instead of a national one.
Schnabel began by unpacking the transatlantic income gap. Measured as GDP per capita adjusted for the cost of living, the euro area ranks below other advanced economies. But an employee in the United States works about 40 days more a year than one in the euro area, and a simple counterfactual in which Europeans worked American hours, with productivity per hour and employment unchanged, would raise euro area real GDP per capita by 21%, closing about two-thirds of the gap. Income is also more evenly shared: the top 10% of US earners take about 37% of post-tax national income, against about 27% in the euro area. In her words, the typical American lives in a $45,000 economy, not a $67,000 one.
The real weakness, she said, is productivity growth. Output per hour has risen more slowly than in peer economies over three decades, reflecting less capital deepening, smaller firms and slower diffusion of technology. Europe's gap with the US widened in the early 2000s because it adopted ICT more slowly, and one reason was firm size: in the US, firms with more than 250 employees account for almost 60% of employment, against about 20% in many euro area countries.
Internal barriers in the Single Market are estimated to equal tariffs of 96% for services and 67% for goods, and in services, about 75% of gross value added, intra-EU trade is no higher than trade with non-EU countries. Founders face a patchwork of legal systems, and many incorporate in Delaware long before they have a US presence.
Under a 28th regime, which the European Commission calls EU Inc., a company could incorporate as a European firm with one set of rules for core company law, governance, shareholder rights and employee financial compensation, through a quick, cheap and fully digital process open to all sizes and sectors. Schnabel said it should be created by an EU regulation directly applicable in all member states, as in the current proposal, to avoid 27 versions of the 28th regime. It would not touch labour law, social security or tax.

Why it matters
An ECB board member endorsing a company-law reform is unusual, and the argument she uses ties it to the central bank's own concern: weak productivity growth limits how much the euro area can grow without inflation. Her insistence on a regulation rather than a directive is the detail that will decide whether the proposal delivers what she describes.