Rate Brief ENDE

Tightening without a tight labour market: Bowman, Lombardelli and the Riksbank on 10 November

Three central bank texts published on 10 November describe economies in different places but reach for the same argument: rates may need to rise even though the labour market is not the source of inflation.

The descriptions of the jobs market are strikingly similar. Fed Vice Chair for Supervision Michelle Bowman calls the US market low-hiring and low-firing: the job-finding rate is low, especially for new entrants, long-term unemployment is rising, layoffs are down, and wage growth of about 3.1% is in her view not inflationary (Federal Reserve). Bank of England Deputy Governor Clare Lombardelli uses almost the same words for the UK, cooling through weaker hiring rather than firing, and adds a long-run decline in job mobility, with job-to-job moves now a little above 2% a quarter against more than 3% thirty years ago (Bank of England).

Yet both lean hawkish. Bowman says there is "still work to do" with core PCE inflation likely at 3.3% in October, though she weighs the cost of further tightening for rate-sensitive sectors. Lombardelli, after voting with the 8-1 majority to raise Bank Rate to 4%, sees a likely case for a further rise. Their reasons sit outside the labour market: energy, tariffs and AI-related demand in Bowman's breakdown, a larger and longer energy shock in Lombardelli's.

Lombardelli adds a twist that links the two halves. If jobseekers are poorly matched to the openings that exist, higher unemployment may do less to cool wages than in the past. A weak labour market, in other words, need not be a disinflationary one.

The Riksbank minutes show the same logic from a smaller, more open economy. All five board members backed the rise to 2% on 3 November, and their reasons were energy, with oil up about 50% since early summer, a weak krona and import prices up nearly 15% since the war began, rather than wage pressure (Riksbank).

Tightening without a tight labour market: Bowman, Lombardelli and the Riksbank on 10 November
Tightening without a tight labour market: Bowman, Lombardelli and the Riksbank on 10 November — Rate Brief

Where the views part

The difference is in how firmly each commits. Bowman stresses the costs of tightening and the data still to come before December. Lombardelli calls her judgement conditional and gradual. In Stockholm, Aino Bunge expects further increases but only if the outlook holds, evaluated step by step. At the same conference, the ECB's Philip Lane argued that a stated reaction function guides markets better than promises about rates, which is what all three are offering here.

What to watch

With labour markets no longer the trigger, the deciding data are energy prices and the pass-through into core prices and pay: the October PCE report in the US, UK pay data, and Swedish import prices.